Enlightenment theories and Virtue ethics

John, a recent university graduate has been hired by a Web design consultancy company to interview their staff to ascertain their current knowledge. The aim of the study is to inform the company about the type of training courses they need to implement. The objective is to highlight areas of overall weakness as opposed to individual shortcomings. Despite this, the type of data John collects will be able to identify individual staff weaknesses. Informed consent clearly states that comments made to John by interviewees are to remain private. Following the study, the Vice President of the company approaches John, asking him “who did well in the study?” John, afraid he will lose his job, proceeds to give the vice-president the key findings, including those identifying individual staff weaknesses.

 

Analyse whether John’s relay of his findings from the staff interview process is an ethical action according to the Enlightenment theories and Virtue ethics. Consider how all stakeholders are affected in your answer. Based on this analysis, conclude whether it is moral for John to have provided the findings of the interview process to the company.

Details about the accuracy of the algorithm

NotAnonCo has developed a machine learning application to determine the identity of users who post anonymous comments (e.g., using pseudonyms or fake names) in public social media websites (e.g., YouTube, blog comments, etc). The algorithm compares the content of posts made with the same pseudonyms, across multiple social media websites, and compares the post content against public information (e.g., available from Facebook).

 

NotAnonCo promotes their service to various types of organisations for a fee. For example, some clients have used the service to check the suitability of new employees. Other clients use the service to identify customers who have posted negative reviews.

 

NotAnonCo does not provide any details about the accuracy of the algorithm. Some client organisations have received complaints after potential employees or customers have suffered consequences (such as being refused credit for home loans, not being considered for lucrative job offers, etc) after their identity was incorrectly linked to anonymous posts made by other people.

 

Who is morally responsible for the negative consequences suffered by people whose details were incorrectly linked to anonymous posts? Analyse each stakeholder’s responsibility and provide reasons to support your arguments.

What can be changed to improve the roster process

There was a complaint on Friday night.

•The host of the Fundraising function complained that there was not enough staff for the guest to get a drink on arrival. Some guests waited an unacceptable 30 min for a drink.
•Give two detailed recommendations of what can be changed to improve the roster process and ensure the issue does not arise again.
•One recommendations needs to be for the supervisor on the day, and one for the roster manager.

Methods of hazard identification

 

A hotel establishment in US, has 35 employees who work an average of 8 hours per day for 280 days a year. In the past year, the employer reported 12 injuries for a total lost time of 50 days. Furthermore, there was a minor fire in the main kitchen. While the fire did not result in any injuries, it led to the closure of the restaurant and room services for 20 days.

To reduce injury and severity rates, you, as the head of the occupational health and safety of the hotel, have been asked to train three staff managers on the methods of hazard identification as they apply to this context. Briefly describe three methods of hazard identification you would visit.

positive learning and development culture

. The term ‘talent management’ is more recently being used to describe the challenge of getting the right person in the right job at the right time. What factors impact the organization’s ability to manage its talent effectively? 3. Attracting talent from within can be very simple and cost-effective, as well as creating a positive learning and development culture. Describe the key problems that recruiting internally can create for an organization?

Development of WHS legislation

Trade unions have been heavily involved in contributing to the development of Work Health and Safety legislation in many countries, to represent their members’ interest and, more broadly, to strengthen their range of legitimate interests in negotiations with management. Discuss both sides of the following statement: ‘Unions have led the development of WHS legislation, while management has largely resisted it’.

Context of training and development

Discus the context of training and development with respect to the current training situation for pool operators. (Use figure 1.2 the context of training and development) to explain your answer. Now explain the situation if training becomes mandatory. What factors in the model will change, and what are the implications? What if a bylaw requires operators to post inspection results? What if operators can be fined for infractions?

Coal India’s recruitment binge

Coal India’s recruitment binge The global economy has created a complex and dynamic environment in which organisations must learn to compete effectively in order to achieve sustainable growth. The global environment has not only changed the way business is conducted, but has also created the need for organisations to manage their talent within the global context. India has its challenges: it will increase its working age population by an additional 200 million, and it is estimated that 70 per cent of Indians will be of working age by 2025. However, this could easily become a disaster if the substantial government initiatives aimed at enhancing the employability of these workers do not succeed. One major challenge for India is the currently limited employment options for its massive cohort of unskilled contract workers. India also has a problem with only a quarter of university graduates being considered, by industry, to be suitable for employment. Coal India may be set to change these trends. The state-run mining company has decided to hire 4500 fresh graduates and 40000 labourers over the next three years. At the same time, the company estimates that around 45000 employees are set to retire over the next three years. About 15000 have been retiring each year for the past few years and the trend is expected to continue. By the end of 2018, each of these employees who is retiring would have accumulated approximately 42 years of service. The single largest cost to Coal India is wages and salaries. A few years ago, they represented 44 per cent of all costs, but with recent wage increases, this has now increased to 50 per cent. The vast majority of staff within the company have been coal filers and coal cutters with no formal education. In fact, anyone who had their name registered with a private mining firm before nationalisation automatically became an employee of Coal India without any qualification or age certificate. Questions 1. What are the recruitment and selection challenges for Coal India presented in this case study? 2. What recruitment and selection strategies should be implemented by Coal India to successfully employ the large number of employees needed?

Duties and obligations of an IS professional

Emily works for a small software company and oversees software quality assurance. The company recently developed an inventory control system for a national clothing manufacturer. The system gathers sales information on an hourly basis from clothing retailers nationwide. This information is then used by all departments (including the accounting, shipping, and ordering departments) to control the functions of the clothing manufacturer.

 

Emily suspects that the inventory functions of the system are not sufficiently tested, although they have passed all their contracted (legal) tests. However, she is pressured by her employers to sign off on the software. Whilst she is only required to perform tests which have been agreed to in the original contract, her considerable experience in software testing has led her to be concerned over the quality of the system. Her employers say that they will go out of business if they do not deliver the software on time.

 

Emily knows that if any section of the inventory system fails, it will significantly harm their client and its employees. If the potential failure were to threaten lives, it would be clear to Emily that she should refuse to sign off. But since the degree of threatened harm is less, Emily is faced with a difficult moral decision.

 

Explain the duties and obligations of an IS professional as dictated by the ACS Code of Conduct in relation to the case study. Applicable aspects from the Code of Conduct may include Primacy of the Public Interest, Enhancement of Quality of Life, Honesty, Competence, Professional Development and Professionalism. In your answer explain the aspects of the ACS Code of Conduct that apply to the case study and explain why.

Talent retention

5. Talent retention is one of the key challenges facing organizations. A highly skilled and diverse workforce is required to deal with the increasingly competitive and changing global environment. How important are career development and management in the retention of a diverse workforce? What skills do managers and leaders need to retain a diverse, skilled, yet flexible, workforce?