A major corporate client to customize and implement a new ERP

Recently, the company has received a new contract/project from a major corporate client to customize and implement a new ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) system to improve productivity. The company has taken. this opportunity to try to start a new collaborative approach within the company, rather than allocating the project to an individual expert.

Assume that your team has been set up as a project team by the senior management and asked for a project plan that shows how the available skills, knowledge, and expertise can best be utilized for different parts of the project. The new system will require;

Planning
Modelling
Coding
Testing
Implementation
Monitoring

Note: You will only be developing a “plan” for the system as a project plan, and not the system itself.

Team Interaction and Workplans

Based on the information provided, as a team, a project plan that at a minimum includes the following structure;

Background/context (from the information provided)
Goals and objectives
Key stakeholders (internal and external stakeholders)
Project overview
Project scope and key tasks (breakdown of key project tasks and milestones) – A workplan outlining tasks and priorities for each member (i.e., Individual workplans)
Role and responsibilities
Key performance indicators (KPIs to measure individual performance)
Collaborative strategy (e.g., communication plan) and strategic networks
Strategies for effective work relationships (diversity, cultural sensitivity, interpersonal styles etc.)
Contingency – e.g., Conflict management strategies
Project timeline and resources
Legislative/regulatory requirements

Labour Markets

Industry Average Weekly Earnings (2019) Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction $2254.16 Utilities $1937.46 Professional, scientific, and technical services $1472.37 Finance and insurance $1347.83 Manufacturing $1157.93 Real Estate and Rental and Leasing $976.63 Health Care and Social Assistance $947.39 Accommodation and food services $428.96 Examine the list of industries and pay rates above 1. Explain possible reasons why each industry has the relative pay level that it does. ❖ Use areas of this Chapter in formulating your response, including: “Understanding Labour Markets; “Compensating Differential”; and, “Defining the Relevant Labour Market”

Interview Questions on Customer Obsession

Amazon Interview Questions on Customer Obsession

  • Who was your most challenging customer?
  • Give me an example of a time when you did not meet a client’s expectation. What happened, and how did you attempt to rectify the situation?
  • When you’re working with a large number of customers, it’s tricky to deliver excellent service to them all. So how do you go about prioritizing your customers’ needs?
  • Tell the story of the last time you had to apologize to someone.

Universal codes of corporate governance

The Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) has forwarded cases that involve 16 Royal Insurance Corporation of Bhutan Ltd (RICBL) staff and three private individuals to the Office of the Attorney General (OAG). It has also written to the board’s chair to take punitive action against them and other officials of the RICBL. The commission has also written to the Governor of Royal Monetary Authority (RMA) to take appropriate actions against them for breaching RMA regulations in force.

The letters were sent on December 29 when the commission forwarded its findings and draft charges in connection to the irrational financial transaction between the RICBL and Nubri Capital Private Ltd and Sherab Reldi Higher Secondary School in Mongar, fraud and collusion in the settlement of false insurance claims, and embezzlement cases.

The letter to the RICBL board pertaining to punitive administrative action against the chief executive officer (CEO), executive director (ED) and other officials stated the essence of the overall findings, summary of the findings referred to the OAG for criminal prosecution, and findings of administrative in nature and recommendation for implementation by the board.

The letter stated that investigation revealed multitude of serious corporate governance glitches and questioned the safety of public funds and credibility of the top leaders in the RICBL. It stated that there is a total lack of ethical tone at the top, which is gradually breeding and expanding.

“Evidences gathered during investigation apparently confirmed serious ethical violations, intimidating behaviour towards employees, fraudulent behaviour, conflicting interest and so on,” the letter to the board stated.

 

(Source: Kuensel, January 12, 2018)

 

  1. Why did RICBL fail to comply with the universal codes of corporate governance? Explain TWO reasons.                                                                                                                                                 (10 marks)
  2. With reference to the DHI Code of Bhutan, suggest THREE changes in the internal control mechanism of RICBL, which could have prevented the organization from getting involved in the above mentioned embezzlement case.                                                                                              (15 marks)

An unsolicited proposal to buy the second largest toy company Hasbro Inc

After some preliminary discussion on January 24, 1996, Mattel made an unsolicited proposal to buy the second largest toy company, Hasbro Inc. Their proposal indicated a fundamental reorganization in the toy industry. The Financial Times (January 27, 1996) stated, “Barbie fluttered her eyelashes at GI Joe and the hearts in Toy Town skipped a beat!” Mattel was strong in dolls with its market leaders Barbie and Ken and was developing joint products with Disney and others. Hasbro was strong in toys for boys such as GI Joe and Tonka trucks as well as in board games. Hasbro’s reaction was to cry, “Monopoly” (one of its board games). Both firms had gaps in creating electronic toys in which foreign competitors such as Nintendo and Sony were leaders.

The phenomenon price of Mattel was $32 per share and that of Hasbro was $30.625. The Mattel offer of 1.67 shares for one share of Hasbro placed a value of $53.44 per share on Hasbro, representing a premium of 74%. Because Hasbro objected immediately, the Hasbro price never went above $40. The price of Mattel moved up by about $1. With 225 million shares, the wealth of Mattel shareholders increased about $225 million. For Hasbro, with 97 million shares outstanding, shareholder wealth increased by almost $1 billion.

Negotiations continued, but Hasbro continued to raise antitrust objections. Finally, on February 3, 1996, it was announced that Mattel would withdraw its offer for Hasbro. John Amerman, the Mattel chairman, stated that in a friendly deal the antitrust barriers could have been resolved in about five months (Wall Street Journal, February 8, 1996, p.B8).

But with the obstacles thrown up by Hasbro, the legal complication would have continued for as long as two years. Mr. Amerman stated that at the end of three years the earnings per share for Mattel would have been unchanged from current projections. He concluded by stating, “why raise our risks?”

The Hasbro stock dropped back to $34.625. The Mattel stock stayed at about $33, about $1 above its prebid price. Mattel said that the costs related to the failed bid would lower their earnings per share for 1996 by about  1cent.

  1. What would have been the business advantages of the combination?      (15 marks)
  2. Would the combination have created market power in the production and distribution of toys? (15 marks)
  3. From the standpoint of U.S. public policy, evaluate the desirability of the combination.    (15 marks)

Invest in the Shell-operated Sakhalin-2 oil and gas project

(75 marks, 15 marks each) Read the case and answer the questions that follow.

The World’s largest integrated oil and gas project is a $22 billion operation located in Yuzhno-Sakhalinsk, in the Siberian Arctic. Originally Royal Dutch Shell had the controlling interest in the venture through its Sakhalin Energy Investment Corp., which had a production-sharing agreement that gave it the right to recoup all of its costs plus a 17.5 percent rate of return before Russia would get a 10 percent share of the hydrocarbons coming from the ground, according to a deal signed in 1996, when oil was $22 a barrel.

Following 12 years of what Fortune magazine described as “a calamitous safety record, a failure to meet local expectations for new roads and schools, a fuel spill in Sakhalin’s third-largest city, and environmental concerns that caused anger and resentment toward Shell’s leadership, earning it a reputation for stubbornness and for consistently misreading political realities,” the Russian government gave Shell an offer it could not refuse—give control of the operation to Russian-owned Gazprom or risk a $50 billion lawsuit over the environmental violations.

In January 2007, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) decided not to invest in the Shell-operated Sakhalin-2 oil and gas project after State-owned Gazprom agreed to become the majority owner, citing environmental concerns. According to St. Petersburg Times, “While the EBRD was under pressure to rule that the project did not meet its strict governmental and social criteria for lending, the decision to pull out was prompted by the new shareholder structure.”

 

(Source: Robert A.G. Monks and Nell Minow. (2016). Corporate Governance. New Delhi: Wiley India Pvt. Ltd)

(15 marks) Why do you think EBRD decided not to invest in the Shell-operated Sakhalin-2 oil and gas project after State-owned Gazprom agreed to become the majority owner of this project? Explain THREE reasons. Suggest THREE changes to be brought about in the Shell’s leadership style, which could have prevented the above mentioned debacle. Suggest THREE changes to be brought about in the risk control mechanism of Shell which could have prevented it from facing environmental violations. Do you think it was a right decision for Gazprom to become the major owner of Sakhalin-2 oil and gas project? Support your answer with THREE  reasons. Fortune magazine had praised Shell for maintaining calamitous safety record. But twelve years later, Shell got involved in environmental violations. Explain THREE reasons why this unfortunate incident happened?

 

Companies Act of Bhutan, 2016,

In the past five years, the unresolved financial irregularities have kept increasing as per the annual audit report (AAR) 2020, conducted by the Royal Audit Authority (RAA). According to the report, unresolved irregularities in 2020 stands at Nu 2,051.23 million (M), an increase of 44.95 percent compared to the irregularities of 2019.

Shortfalls, lapses and deficiencies account to Nu 1,574.24M, followed by non-compliance to laws and rules with Nu 408.86M. Mismanagement accounts to Nu 42.76M, fraud and corruption misused Nu 18.33M, and embezzlement involve Nu 7.83M.

Under the non-budgetary agencies, Bhutan Development Bank Ltd. had irregularities amounting to Nu 311.02M, followed by Royal Insurance Corporation of Bhutan Ltd and Bank of Bhutan with irregularities of Nu 183.44M, and Nu 160.44M, respectively. The report cited that the significant increase of lapses for the non-budgetary agencies was due to a huge portion of non-performing loans.

RAA officials said that auditing was a continuous process and it would be difficult to tell when to subside irregularities. The lack of timely response to the audit report aggravated the irregularities, as per the officials.

 (Source: Kuensel, July 13, 2021)

 

Why do you think the non-budgetary agencies have failed to respond to the RAA’s audit report on time? Explain TWO reasons. ( 10 marks  )With reference to the Companies Act of Bhutan, 2016, suggest THREE changes in the regulatory framework mechanism of non-budgetary agencies, which could have ensured that these agencies are prompt in their response.                                                                                                          (15 marks)

Poor internal control systems

(75 marks, 15 marks each) Read the case and answer the questions that follow.

 

The UK group Marconi plc grew out of GEC, a company built by Lord Weinstock, who bequeathed a set of solid, if unadventurous, manufacturing businesses, with large reserves of cash. On his retirement, Marconi adopted a different strategy—to invest in high-tech enterprises. Within a few years, all of the cash had been spent and the company was over £4 billion in debt. Worse, many of the investments were disasters. In July 2001, the company suspended trading in its shares, warning that profits were likely to halve to around £350 million. The company’s share price fell and the chief executive, Lord Simpson, met strong opposition to his proposal that executive share options should be repriced to reflect the fall. 

Throughout August 2001, the company refused to comment on rumors that things were much worse. No advice was given to investors, the stock exchange, or the Financial Services Authority. Then, in September 2001, the scale of the disaster became clear, when a loss of £327 million for the three months from June were announced. Various operating explanations were forthcoming: the downturn in the high-tech market was global; the internal control systems had failed to identify financial problems fast enough; the corporate centre was out of touch with its struggling divisions. The opinion that this was a case of poor business judgement as a result of complacence, and not due to poor corporate governance.

Where was the board during this developing debacle? The case raises questions far beyond strategic and operational mismanagement. The issues go to the heart of the board structure and director competence. The case for non-executive directors argues that independence allows them to question top management and to make tough-minded calls for change if necessary. Subsequently, some Marconi non-executive directors claimed that they had questioned both the strategic direction and financial situation of the company, but had not received the necessary information. 

A board meeting was called to face the situation, which one director described as ‘Britain’s greatest industrial disaster for decades’. Decisive action was needed. Bonham, as senior non-executive director, took charge. By the end of the meeting, both the chief executive Simpson and the chairman Hurn had been replaced.

 

(Source: Bob Tricker. (2012). Corporate Governance: Principles, Policies, and Practices. Oxford: Oxford University Press)

Some non-executive directors claimed that they had questioned about the strategic direction and financial situation of the company, but had not received the necessary information. Why do you think this happened? Explain THREE reasons. Analyze the intention of the management for not providing any advice to the investors during the time of its crisis? Explain THREE reasons. One of the reasons for the failure of Marconi was its poor internal control systems, which had failed to identify financial problems that the company was facing. Suggest THREE changes that could have been brought about in the internal control systems of the company, which would have prevented its failure. The given case clearly indicates that the company had failed to follow the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. Suggest THREE changes that can be brought about in the operating structure of the company, which would have made it possible for it to abide with clauses of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. Do you think it was a right decision made by Simpson to reprice the share options in order to address the crisis? Support your answer with the help of three reasons.

Employee ownership is an appropriate solution to improve corporate performance

In late 1992, the employees of United Airlines agreed to buy 53% of the company (63% if the stock price hit certain levels in the plan’s first year) in exchange for about $5 billion in wage and work-rule concessions over the next six years. This is the biggest and most dramatic example of a growing trend toward employee ownership. The objective of the employees in designing this deal was to save their jobs. To stay employed, they were willing to pay cuts of 10 to 17 percent. In addition, there were other concessions, like unpaid lunch breaks and reduced pension plan contributions. It is unlikely that they would have been willing to make these concessions without majority ownership to guarantee the management of their choice. Interestingly, however, the 13-member board of directors has seats for only four employee representatives, one from each of the three unions and one to represent non-union employees.

Following severe setbacks, including the post-September 11 increase in expenses and decrease in air travel, United Airlines filed for bankruptcy in late 2002, promising it would be seeking deep cuts from its pilots, mechanics, flight attendants, and other employees, the “owners” of the company. The employees sued the money managers for holding on to the United stock.

Bankruptcy Judge Eugene Wedoff approved United’s plan to terminate employee pensions, clearing the way for the largest corporate-pension default in American history. United made two rounds of severe labor cuts, with more than $3 billion in annual savings. It borrowed $3 billion and emerged from bankruptcy in 2006.

 

(Source: Robert A.G. Monks and Nell Minow. (2016). Corporate Governance, New Delhi: Wiley India 

Pvt. Ltd.)

Do you agree that employee ownership is an appropriate solution to improve corporate performance? Support your view with TWO logical justifications. In context to stakeholder theory, suggest TWO measures to United Airlines which could have saved the company.Explain the TWO dominant reasons which contributed the downfall of United Airlines.

 

 

regulatory mechanism

(40 marks) Read the case and answer the questions that follow.

A day after Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) sought clarification from Paytm on the “significant movement” in its share price, the company said in a filing that it has no information which could have a bearing on the price that it hasn’t disclosed to the stock exchanges. Nonetheless, the stock hit a new all-time low of Rs 520 on March 22, 2022.

Paytm parent company One97 Communications has said in a filing with BSE that its business fundamentals remain robust and that it has shared all information that could have a bearing on its share price with stock exchanges.

The clarification comes a day after BSE sought a clarification from the company on its plummeting share price. BSE said it sought the clarification “to ensure that investors have latest relevant information about the company and to inform the market so that the interest of the investors is safeguarded”.
In its filing, Paytm said it has from time to time made all necessary disclosures to stock exchanges within the stipulated timeline. “The company would also like to point out that the business fundamentals remain robust as demonstrated in our last earnings release dated February 4, 2022. We would like to reiterate that the company is committed to comply with the listing regulations,” it said.

 

(Source: Paytm Puts on a Brave Face. (2022, March 23). Retrieved from 

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/:

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/newsletters/tech-top-5/paytm-puts-on-a-brave-face

uae-crypto-fund-to-bet-big-on-india/articleshow/90400482.cms)

 

 

  1. Do you think Paytm was actually safeguarding the interests of their shareholders? Support your answer with TWO reasons.                                                                                                                    (10 marks)

 

  1. Suggest THREE measures that the board could have brought about in the disclosure policy of the company which could have prevented the problem mentioned in the given case.                     (15 marks)

 

  1. Suggest THREE changes that Paytm could have brought about in their regulatory mechanism which would have addressed the above mentioned problem in the given case.                                    (15 marks)