Existing audit process of FIFA

The FIFA scandal in May 2015 involved the collusion between FIFA executives, sports marketing executives and officials of continental football bodies. It happened when Swiss authorities raided a hotel in Zurich and several FIFA executives were arrested. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has cited more than 40 defendants in the FIFA scandal. Some charges involved bids for World Cups and for marketing and broadcast deals that amounted to nearly $150 million. Future World Cups are now in question — the scandal has caused the bidding process for the 2026 World Cup to be suspended. Proposed changes have been made, but only time will tell in an organization that has historically dealt with bribery and corruption.

(Source: https://acfeinsights.squarespace.com/acfe-insights/2017/1/18/10-infamous-fraud-cases-of-the-21st-century)

 

Explain any THREE changes that could have been brought about in the existing audit process of FIFA that would have prevented this corruption in the organization.

Implementation of appropriate internal control mechanisms

(15 marks) Read the case and answer the question that follows.

 

In 2002, the WorldCom scandal became one of the largest accounting frauds in history when the company revealed its wrongdoing and was subsequently forced to file bankruptcy and write off $50 billion in losses. The scandal began when WorldCom CEO Bernie Ebbers employed a business strategy of achieving growth through acquisitions. He acquired MCI Communications and then proposed a merger with Sprint, but was forced to abandon the Sprint merger in 2000. Determined to show increased revenue despite a slow-down in mergers and acquisitions, Ebbers manipulated the books to satisfy Wall Street’s expectations. The scheme was detected when a capital expenditures audit revealed suspicious journal entries. WorldCom’s internal audit team discovered improper accounting in expenses over five quarters.

(Source: https://acfeinsights.squarespace.com/acfe-insights/2017/1/18/10-infamous-fraud-cases-of-the-21st-century)

 

Explain any THREE ways how implementation of appropriate internal control mechanisms could have helped in preventing this accounting fraud in WorldCom.

Corporate corruption and accounting fraud

Enron Corporation collapsed in October 2001 due to its involvement in corporate corruption and accounting fraud. The top executives failed to discharge their duties and responsibilities towards their employees and the society. The company had hidden facts to the regulators with fake holdings and off-the-books accounting. As a result the shareholders of the organization lost $74 billion, which ultimately led to its bankruptcy.

 

Suggest and explain any THREE strategies that Enron Corporation could have implemented to ensure good corporate governance regulation in the organization.

Responsible for the collapse of Enron

Enron was founded in 1985, and as one of the world’s leading electricity, natural gas, communications and pulp and paper companies before it bankrupted in late 2001, its annual revenues rose from about $9 billion in 1995 to over $100 billion in 2000.

Throughout the late 1990s, Enron was almost universally considered as one of the United States’ most innovative companies. The company continued to build power plants and operate gas lines, but it became better known for its unique trading businesses.

At the end of 2001 it was revealed that its reported financial condition was sustained substantially by institutionalized, systematic, and creatively planned accounting fraud. According to data, the drop of Enron’s stock price from $90 per share in mid‐2000 to less than $1 per share at the end of 2001, caused shareholders to lose nearly $11 billion. And Enron revised its financial statement for the previous five years and found that there was $586million in losses. Enron filed for bankruptcy on December 2, 2001.

  1. Who do you think was responsible for the collapse of Enron? (15 marks)
  2. What control mechanisms could there have been to prevent such a scandal? (15 marks)
  3. What is the connection between the Enron scandal and the Sarbanes‐Oxley Act? (15 marks)

Emails from clients concerning online scams

Last year China Checkup received many emails from clients concerning online scams. In one such case Cheng had placed an order on their online shop sell-buying.com, wired money to their assigned Chinese bank account and received an invoice for their order. But it turned out that the invoice was a fake, sent only to buy time, the supposedly decent dealer stopped taking calls and replying to emails. Finally it became obvious that the company was in fact a fictitious one. Investigation The Company listed on the invoice as the seller, “Shanghai Beiwei Mechanical Electronics Technology Co. Ltd.” was found not to exist, while the name of “China Pacific Insurance (Group) Co. Ltd.”, China’s second largest property insurance company, seemingly was put on the invoice just to make it look more authentic.

Some customers noted that while they were visiting some genuine online shops they were actually redirected to fake and similar websites. Many big online shops like Alibaba.com are suffering huge losses, because of these scams as many customers are falling prey to this kind of trap. There have been around 300000 cases of e-frauds in china totaling, around RMB 42 Million.

 

a. Analyze the case and suggest how Mr. Cheng could have avoided the online fraud and the losses he suffered?

b. Analyze the various types of e-frauds detailed in the case.

Reporting structure or incentive structure or set of guidelines for employees

Q4.  Read the following case study and answer the questions.                                  (2×10=20 Marks)

Who pays the penalty when babies drink sugar water?

How do you punish a corporation? The president and vice-president of Beech-Nut admitted that they knowingly permitted adulterated apple juice to be sold for babies. The babies who drank the juice, of course, had no way of knowing that the juice was not right, and no way of communicating it if they did. The company pled guilty to 215 counts of violating federal food and drug laws, and paid a $2 million fine. According to the New York Times, its market share dropped 15 percent. The president and vice-president were not fired. On the contrary – the company paid all of their legal fees and their salaries until their appeals ran out. No one from the company ever went to jail or paid a fine out of his own pocket. On the witness stand, one of the executives explained his decision to continue to market the adulterated juice: “What was I supposed to do? Close down the factory?”

 

  1. What was the executive supposed to do?
  2. What reporting structure or incentive structure or set of guidelines for employees would be most likely to achieve the best result for the company and its customers?

Bhutan National Bank Limited (BNBL)

Bhutan National Bank Limited (BNBL) has breached its own human resources (HR) policy by compulsorily retiring 10 support staff who submitted forged documents with service benefits.

This was found when the Royal Audit Authority’s (RAA) conducted compliance auditing in the bank.

BNBL paid Nu 153,932.02 as retirement benefits to the staff.

RAA also found that three staff who submitted forged documents are still serving in the bank and details of two staff who were also accused of submitting false documents could not be verified, as BNBL claimed they couldn’t validate with schools.

RAA pointed out that although the bank was aware of such forgery, the staff were made to resign compulsorily with service benefits instead of terminating them as per the bank’s human resources (HR) policy. “The bank’s management failed to exercise due diligence during the document verification process where most of the staff recruited had forged their academic results.”

 

Rinzin, Y.C. (2020, April 11). BNBL Recruited Support Staff Who Submitted Forged Documents, Thimphu, Bhutan: Kuensel

 

  1. (10 marks) “Although the bank was aware of such forgery, the staff were made to resign compulsorily with service benefits instead of terminating them as per the bank’s human resources (HR) policy.”

With reference to the above mentioned statement, why do you think the board made this decision? Explain your answer with the help of two justifiable reasons.

 

  1. (15 marks) With reference to the DHI Code of Corporate Governance, what are the three changes that could have been included in the current operating structure of BNBL, which could have prevented the forgery?

Operating structure of BDBL

After reviewing the embezzlement and fraud case of the Bhutan Development Bank Limited (BDBL) for 11 months, the Office of the Attorney General (OAG), charged 12 people to Thimphu dzongkhag court yesterday.

The case, involving a BDBL official and 55 clients, amounts to Nu 576.469 million (M), where the BDBL official is accused of gaining about Nu 422M by fiddling with the system to enhance loans and collateral mortgage without the knowledge of the bank’s credit and legal divisions.

OAG charged the main accused, BDBL’s project officer, Pema Nidup, for 79 counts of embezzlement through illegal enhancements of loan amounting to Nu 403M.

He was also charged with three counts of embezzlement through forging cheques amounting to Nu 26M.

A reliable source told the media that there were several issues of not following established procedures and also lack of supervisory control that contributed to the fraud happening

 

(Source: Dema, T. (2018, May 22). 12 People Charged in BDBL Embezzlement and Fraud Case, Thimphu, Bhutan: Kuensel)

 

  1. (10 marks) What are the two changes that could have been brought about in the operating structure of BDBL to prevent the scam? Explain each of these reasons.

 

  1. (15 marks)With reference to the Companies Act of Bhutan, 2016, what are the three changes that could have been included in the supervisory control mechanism of the bank, which could have prevented the scam? Explain each of these changes.
    1.        Analyze five Corporate Governance issues at Satyam which violated all the principles of corporate governance.

Aggressive management style of corporate governance

Siemens is Europe’s largest engineering group, manufacturing a diverse range of products from power plants to home appliances, computers to railway engines. Headquartered in Germany, the company has a two-tier board.

In 2007, the chief executive Klaus Kleinfeld, challenged the supervisory board to renew his contract or to accept his resignation. The proposal failed to get necessary votes in the supervisory board and he resigned.

Previously, Kleinfeld had successfully run Siemens’ American operations, listing the company on the New York Stock Exchange in the process. He had served as an outside director on the boards of the major bank Citigroup and the American aluminum company Alcoa. He was recognized as a capable leader. Under his guidance, the Siemens Group had recently reported a 10% increase in revenue and a 36% increase in profits.

But both the union and the shareholder representatives on the supervisory board disliked his aggressive management style. Rumors about him circulated among board members. Heinrich von Pierer, the head of the supervisory board, resigned and was replaced by Gerhard Cromme, a pioneer of corporate governance in Germany.

 

(Source: Bob Tricker. (2012). Corporate Governance: Principles, Policies, and Practices. Oxford: Oxford University Press)

(15 marks) Suggest three measures that Siemens AG could have incorporated to comply with the international codes of corporate governance.

(10 marks) Do you think aggressive management style of corporate governance is harmful for the long-term sustainability of Siemens AG? Justify giving two reasons.

(10 marks) What could be the two probable reasons for the shareholder representatives to dislike the operational approach of Kleinfeld? Explain each of these reasons.

(10 marks) If you were in place of Heinrich von Pierer, suggest two measures that you would have implemented in order to maintain a good board-management relationship.

 

Industry Average Weekly Earnings

Industry Average Weekly Earnings (2019) Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction $2254.16 Utilities $1937.46 Professional, scientific, and technical services $1472.37 Finance and insurance $1347.83 Manufacturing $1157.93 Real Estate and Rental and Leasing $976.63 Health Care and Social Assistance $947.39 Accommodation and food services $428.96 Examine the list of industries and pay rates above 1. Explain possible reasons why each industry has the relative pay level that it does.